If we take the Ground Zero Mosque for example, there are strong feelings against its construction because of its sensitive location near ground zero. One side of the argument is that Muslims shouldn’t build their mosque close to Ground Zero out of respect and consideration of the 9/11 victims who died in the horrifying attack. This side opposing its construction says allowing Muslims to build a mosque in this location will show terrorists that they have won the war. I respect the innocent victims that lost their lives due to the 9/11 attacks and thus support the Ground Zero Memorial on the actual land where the twin towers once stood as a place for victims to always be remebered and honored. Muslims are not trying to build a mosque there because they respect the memorial as a place to remember the nation’s loss on that day, which includes Muslims who also lost members working in these buildings. The proposed site for the “mosque”, as the media refers to it, while it is actually a community center open to the public, is a couple of blocks away from the Ground Zero. This highlights that there is no disrespect to the Ground Zero victims because the Islamic Center is not on the Ground Zero Memorial.
The argument that building an Islamic center is letting the terrorists “win” is also a poor argument. Unfortunately 13 Muslim terrorist attacked the U.S. on 9/11, but that does not mean that all Muslims are terrorist, in actuality these terrorist are extremist. Due to anti Muslim sentiments people just affiliate all Muslims with terror. So the argument purposed by those opposed the Islamic Center holds not true. The “terrorists” won’t have won anything because it’s not the terrorist who we are letting build this center but rather the American Muslims.
The right winged Christian Republicans has been the main force opposing the Islamic Center by coming up with discrimantory attacks against Muslims. As I’ve already mentioned both these opposing reasons do not make valid arguments against the Islamic Center’s construction, however the Republican goal seems to be to increase Islamophobia among U.S. citizens inorder to gain more support of those who are anti-Muslim. Republicans are conservative Christians so they are favored by individuals who don’t like the liberalism of Muslim activity in the U.S. So in a sense one major aspect of their campaign is Muslim tolerance. If they can persuade more people to become intolerant to Muslims by believing they are dangerous terrorists, then they will have more supporters voting for them when Election Day comes around. Although President Obama has mentioned several times that the U.S. is not at war with Islam and Muslims have the right to religious freedom, citizens are having a hard time believing Obama while Republicans are trying to distort the image of Muslims for their own political gain.
Due to politics Republicans have been trying to destroy the image of Muslims in order to achieve success in their personal political agenda. By deliberately increasing Islamophobia there will be more anti Muslim expression thus there will always be discrimination against Muslims in the U.S. Its politics that are creating the stereotypes and hate crimes that exists today. This can be depicted with the fact that the construction of the Islamic Center has been proposed for a while, but its debate didn’t actually start till recently. Why is that? Possibly because its election time and republicans are trying to get more supports by stirring up anti-Muslim feelings in the nation. Whats worse is the lack of education about Islam has led people to accepting false facts presented by the Republicans.
Your blog does a good job with showing the two sides of the arguemnet. You show how the two political sides are differing in their approaches to this sensitive subject. You also do a good job of showing where people have gotten these misbeliefs of the Islamic faith. I think that you might want to give more examples of discrimination of the Islamic faith. The only example you give is the Mosque, and i just think that maybe some more examples would help strenghten your arguement. I also feel that there are more causes for the discrimination than just 9/11 and Republican camaigning. The war which you did touch on i know has caused a lot of anit-muslim sentiment and you could maybe talk about that a little more and explain why that has caused these beliefs. Overall it was a good post and i enjoyed reading it.
ReplyDeleteI agree that you have a done a fine job of discussing your topic by describing good examples from both sides, What i was wondering was if you had any concrete examples of republican terror campaigning? i know that it is happening, but it still comes as a shock that people are not above playing off of peoples 9/11 fears. i think it is time to move on. Also what is your opinion on the community center? can you understand peoples concerns, or are they just ludicrous? I personally think it is nothing but fear-mongering extremists trying to scare the american public away from equality, but my opinion doesnt have a factual base, and is most likly bias, i would like to know your opinion.
ReplyDeleteI personally believe the Islamic Center should be constructed. I mean if the government prevents its construction it would be unconstitutional towards those who are building it. For the sake of our political system we have to grant them the right to exercise their freedom granted to them by the law. Also I think having this building may provide the potential of decreasing Islamophobia in the community. With more mixing of communication amongst Muslims and non Muslims in the area, the fear many people harbor towards Muslims will start to fade. It’s sad that politicians use peoples fear to gain their support and not only do they use the existing fear that people may have but they also try to increase peoples’ fear. I mean if you think of it it’s a psychological trick in which we are voting for the individuals who grow these fears in our minds to help us end them. An example of a politician that is actually running for the elections in November who is a strong anti Muslim advocate is Lou Ann Zelenik. I have talked about some of the movements she has been a part of in the Tennessee blog.
ReplyDelete